Skip to main content

HELOC vs Personal Line of Credit in Canada 2026

Updated

Quick Comparison

FeatureHELOCPersonal Line of Credit
Secured byYour homeUnsecured (no collateral)
Typical ratePrime + 0.5-1.0%Prime + 2-5%
Rate (early 2025)5.45-5.95%6.95-9.95%
Credit limitUp to 65% of home equity$5,000-$50,000 typically
Minimum credit score680+660+
Requires home ownershipYesNo
Appraisal requiredYesNo
Setup costs$200-$1,500Usually $0
Time to approve2-6 weeks1-5 days
RiskYour home is collateralNo collateral at risk

Interest Rate Comparison

Current Rates (Early 2025, Prime = 4.95%)

LenderHELOC RatePersonal LOC Rate
RBCPrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 3-4% (7.95-8.95%)
TDPrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 2.5-5% (7.45-9.95%)
BMOPrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 3-4.5% (7.95-9.45%)
ScotiabankPrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 2-4% (6.95-8.95%)
CIBCPrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 3-5% (7.95-9.95%)
TangerinePrime + 0.50% (5.45%)Prime + 2.5-4% (7.45-8.95%)
National BankPrime + 0.55% (5.50%)Prime + 3-4.5% (7.95-9.45%)

Annual Interest Cost Comparison

BalanceHELOC (5.45%)Personal LOC (8.45%)Difference
$10,000$545$845$300/year
$25,000$1,363$2,113$750/year
$50,000$2,725$4,225$1,500/year
$100,000$5,450$8,450$3,000/year
$150,000$8,175N/A (too high for unsecured)

How Much Can You Borrow?

HELOC

FactorRule
Maximum LTV for HELOC alone65% of home value
Maximum combined LTV (mortgage + HELOC)80% of home value
Formula(Home value × 80%) – mortgage balance = max HELOC
Home ValueMortgage OwingMax HELOC
$400,000$250,000$70,000
$500,000$300,000$100,000
$600,000$300,000$180,000
$800,000$400,000$240,000
$1,000,000$500,000$300,000

Personal Line of Credit

FactorTypical Range
Minimum limit$5,000
Maximum limit$35,000-$50,000
Based onIncome, credit score, debt ratios
Income requirementVaries (generally $40,000+ for higher limits)

Qualification Requirements

RequirementHELOCPersonal LOC
Minimum credit score680+660+
Home ownershipYesNo
Sufficient equityYes (20%+ equity typically)N/A
Income verificationYesYes
Debt service ratiosGDS < 39%, TDS < 44%TDS < 40-44%
AppraisalYes (bank may cover cost)No
Legal/registration fees$500-$1,500$0
Time to approve2-6 weeks1-5 business days

Pros and Cons

HELOC

ProsCons
Lowest rates availableYour home is at risk
High credit limits ($100K+)Requires home ownership + equity
Interest-only paymentsSetup costs ($200-$1,500)
Tax-deductible interest (if used for investment)Longer approval process
Access to large amountsVariable rate risk
Can be used for renovationsReduces available equity

Personal Line of Credit

ProsCons
No collateral neededHigher interest rates
Quick approval (days)Lower limits ($5K-$50K)
No setup costsNo tax deduction on interest
Available to rentersHarder to qualify for large amounts
No home equity requiredMay be reduced or cancelled by bank
Simpler applicationInterest-only trap

When to Use Each

Choose a HELOC

SituationWhy
Home renovationsLower rate, potentially increases home value
Debt consolidation (large amount)Save thousands in interest
Investment (Smith Manoeuvre)Interest becomes tax-deductible
Emergency fund alternativeLow-cost access to funds
Bridging between house sale/purchaseShort-term access to equity
Need $50,000+Personal LOC limits are too low

Choose a Personal LOC

SituationWhy
You don’t own a homeOnly option
Need $5,000-$25,000Quick, no setup costs
Short-term borrowingDon’t want to risk home
Smaller renovationsNot worth HELOC setup cost
Emergency expensesFast access
Travel or large purchaseManageable amount, quick payoff

The Smith Manoeuvre (HELOC Tax Strategy)

StepWhat Happens
1Pay down mortgage to build equity
2Borrow from HELOC (readvanceable mortgage)
3Invest HELOC funds in income-producing investments
4Deduct HELOC interest on your tax return
5Use investment income + tax savings to pay down mortgage faster
6Repeat — convert non-deductible mortgage to deductible investment debt

This only works with a HELOC, not a personal line of credit, because the borrowed funds must be used for income-producing investments and the loan must be secured.

Repayment Comparison

FeatureHELOCPersonal LOC
Minimum paymentInterest onlyInterest only (some require 1-3% of balance)
Payment on $50K at 5.5%$229/month (interest only)$352/month (interest only at 8.5%)
Risk of interest-only trapHigh — balance never decreasesHigh — balance never decreases
Recommended approachPay interest + principal monthlyPay interest + principal monthly
Time to pay off $50K (5% extra)~12 years~10 years (higher payment)

Alternatives to Consider

AlternativeRateBest For
Fixed-rate personal loan6-10%Fixed payments, forced payoff
Balance transfer credit card0% for 6-12 monthsShort-term, small amounts
Mortgage refinance4-6%Large amounts, fixed payment
Second mortgage6-12%Need equity access, denied HELOC
RRSP loanPrime to Prime + 1%Short-term RRSP contribution