Chargeback vs Dispute: What’s the Difference
| Term | What It Means |
|---|---|
| Dispute | You contact your card issuer to report an issue with a charge on your statement |
| Chargeback | The card issuer reverses the transaction and returns the funds to your account |
| Arbitration | If the merchant fights the chargeback and you disagree, the card network (Visa/MC) makes a final decision |
Valid Reasons to Dispute a Charge
| Reason | Example | Likely Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Unauthorized/fraudulent charge | Someone used your card without permission | Chargeback granted (card replaced) |
| Item not received | Online order never arrived | Chargeback granted (with tracking evidence) |
| Item not as described | Received wrong/defective product | Chargeback likely (provide photos) |
| Duplicate charge | Charged twice for the same purchase | Chargeback granted |
| Wrong amount | Charged $500 instead of $50 | Chargeback granted |
| Recurring charge after cancellation | Gym kept charging after you cancelled | Chargeback likely (provide cancellation proof) |
| Service not provided | Flight cancelled, no refund issued | Chargeback likely |
| Merchant went out of business | Paid but business closed before delivery | Chargeback likely |
NOT Valid for Chargeback
| Situation | Why | What to Do Instead |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer’s remorse | You changed your mind but product was as described | Request a return/refund from the merchant |
| Family member’s authorized purchase | Not fraud if you gave them permission | Discuss with the family member |
| Forgot about a subscription | You signed up and forgot | Cancel and request a refund from the merchant |
| Dispute over quality (subjective) | Restaurant food was “okay” but not amazing | Leave a review; not grounds for chargeback |
Step-by-Step: How to Dispute a Charge
| Step | Action | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Contact the merchant first | Call or email the merchant to request a refund or resolution | Do this first (required by most issuers) |
| 2. Gather documentation | Receipts, order confirmations, screenshots, photos of defective items | Before calling your issuer |
| 3. Contact your card issuer | Call the number on the back of your card or use the app/online banking | Within 30 days of the statement |
| 4. File the dispute | Provide details: date, amount, merchant, reason, evidence | Issuer provides dispute form |
| 5. Temporary credit issued | Issuer may provide a provisional credit while investigating | Within 5–10 business days |
| 6. Investigation | Issuer contacts the merchant for their response | 30–90 day investigation period |
| 7. Resolution | Issuer decides based on evidence from both sides | Notified by letter or online |
| 8. Escalate if needed | If denied, request re-review or file a complaint with FCAC | Within the appeal window |
How to Contact Major Card Issuers
| Issuer | Dispute Method | Phone |
|---|---|---|
| TD | EasyWeb online banking or call | 1-800-983-8472 |
| RBC | RBC Online Banking or call | 1-800-769-2512 |
| CIBC | CIBC Online Banking or call | 1-800-465-4653 |
| BMO | BMO Online Banking or call | 1-800-263-2263 |
| Scotiabank | Scotia Online or call | 1-800-472-6842 |
| Amex | Amex App or online or call | 1-800-869-3016 |
| National Bank | Online banking or call | 1-888-835-6281 |
| Capital One | Online banking or call | 1-800-481-3239 |
Dispute Timeline
| Stage | Timeframe |
|---|---|
| Notice the charge | Check statements regularly |
| Contact merchant | Give 7–14 days for response |
| File dispute with card issuer | Within 30 days of statement (120 days max from transaction) |
| Provisional credit | 5–10 business days |
| Issuer investigation | 30–90 days |
| Merchant response window | 20–45 days |
| Final decision | Within 90 days of filing |
| Appeal/re-dispute (if denied) | Usually 10–30 days after decision |
Tips for a Successful Dispute
| Tip | Why |
|---|---|
| Try the merchant first | Issuers require proof you attempted to resolve directly |
| Document everything | Emails, screenshots, tracking numbers, photos |
| Dispute promptly | Delays reduce your chances of success |
| Be specific | State the date, amount, and exactly what went wrong |
| Keep records of the dispute process | Note dates, representative names, reference numbers |
| Follow up if you don’t hear back | Call your issuer if the investigation is taking longer than expected |