Skip to main content

Selling Your Home and Renting in Retirement: A Financial Comparison for Canadians

Updated

The big question

You’ve spent 25 or 30 years paying off your mortgage. Your home is now your largest asset — possibly worth $500,000 to $1.5 million or more. Should you:

A) Stay in the house, live mortgage-free, and leave it to your heirs?

B) Sell, invest the equity, rent a smaller place, and use the income and capital for a better retirement?

There’s no universal answer, but laying out the numbers shows what the answer depends on.


The financial comparison

Scenario: $800,000 home, mortgage-free

Option A — Stay in the home

Annual cost of owning (mortgage-free)Amount
Property tax$5,500
Home insurance$2,000
Utilities$4,200
Maintenance (1.5% of value)$12,000
Major repair reserve$3,000
Total annual cost$26,700
Monthly equivalent$2,225

Your home equity ($800,000) is illiquid — tied up in the walls. You can access it only through a HELOC, reverse mortgage, or selling.

Option B — Sell, invest proceeds, and rent

ItemAmount
Sale price$800,000
Selling costs (5%)−$40,000
Net proceeds$760,000
Rental cost (2-bedroom apartment)$26,400/year ($2,200/month)
Renter’s insurance$300/year
Utilities (if not included)$1,800/year
Total annual rental cost$28,500
Monthly equivalent$2,375

Investment income from $760,000:

Investment strategyAnnual returnAnnual income
Conservative (GICs, bonds, 4%)4%$30,400
Balanced (60/40 portfolio, 5–6%)5.5%$41,800
Income-focused (dividends + bonds, 4.5%)4.5%$34,200

At a 4% return, the invested proceeds generate $30,400/year before tax, enough to cover $28,500 in rental costs with $1,900 left over. The owner in Option A pays $26,700 a year to keep the house and gets no income from the $800,000 of equity, though the house itself may rise in value (see below).


20-year projection

Key assumptions

  • Home appreciation: 3% a year, tax-free (principal residence).
  • Ownership costs ($26,700 in year 1) rise 2% a year; the owner pays them from other income.
  • Rental costs ($28,500 in year 1) rise 2.5% a year. The renter pays the extra cost of renting over owning ($1,800 in year 1) from the portfolio, so both households have the same other income to spend.
  • Portfolio return: shown at 5% and at 4% a year, after any tax.

Net wealth after 20 years

YearStay: home valueStay: home value after 5% selling costsRent: portfolio at 5%Rent: portfolio at 4%
0$800,000$760,000$760,000$760,000
5$927,419$881,048$958,077$912,975
10$1,075,133$1,021,376$1,205,128$1,093,451
15$1,246,374$1,184,055$1,513,490$1,306,216
20$1,444,889$1,372,645$1,898,711$1,556,900

Each year, the portfolio grows by its return and pays the gap between rental and ownership costs: balance × (1 + return) − (28,500 × 1.025^year − 26,700 × 1.02^year), counting the first year as year 0.

What decides it: with the home rising 3% a year, the renter’s portfolio needs about 3.4% a year after tax to end up level with the owner’s net home value at year 20. Below that, staying builds more wealth; above it, selling does. Taxes matter: interest and most investment income outside a TFSA are taxed each year, while the home’s gain is tax-free. The renter also has the capital in liquid form throughout, while the owner’s wealth stays in the house until it is sold.


Tax implications

Selling your principal residence

  • Capital gains tax: $0. The principal residence exemption eliminates tax on the gain.
  • Report on your tax return: You still report the sale on Schedule 3 (and Form T2091), even though no tax is owed.
  • Entire gain is sheltered — whether you made $200,000 or $800,000 on the property.

Investment income in retirement

Once you invest the proceeds, investment income is taxable:

Income typeTax treatment
GIC / bond interestFully taxable at your marginal rate
Canadian dividendsEligible for the dividend tax credit, so taxed at lower rates than interest
Capital gains (from selling investments)50% inclusion rate — only half is taxable
Return of capital (some funds)A return of capital isn't taxed in the year you receive it. It reduces the adjusted cost base (ACB) of your units.
TFSA withdrawalsTax-free
RRSP/RRIF withdrawalsFully taxable at marginal rate

TFSA room: someone who has been eligible since 2009 and never contributed has $109,000 of room in 2026. Income earned inside a TFSA is tax-free, which helps the sell-and-rent option.

OAS clawback risk

Investment income from non-registered accounts may push your income above the OAS clawback threshold: $93,454 of 2025 income, which sets the recovery tax for July 2026 to June 2027. For every dollar above the threshold, you repay 15 cents of OAS.

2025 net incomeOAS clawback (monthly)
Up to $93,454$0
$100,000$82/month
$120,000$332/month
$152,062+ (age 65–74)Full OAS clawed back

Each row: (income − threshold) × 15% ÷ 12.

The investment structure (TFSA room, capital gains versus interest, the timing of RRIF withdrawals) affects how much clawback applies.


Lifestyle considerations

Advantages of selling and renting

BenefitDetails
Freedom from maintenanceNo more roof repairs, furnace breakdowns, or lawn care
Downsizing flexibilityRent a smaller space that fits your actual needs
Geographic freedomMove to a new city, live near grandchildren, try a different lifestyle
TravelLock-and-leave — no house to worry about while travelling
Access to capital$500K–$1M+ in liquid investments vs. illiquid home equity
Simplified financesOne monthly rent payment vs. property tax + insurance + maintenance + utilities

Advantages of staying

BenefitDetails
Stability and communityYour neighbourhood, your neighbours, your routines
No rent increasesOwnership costs rise slowly; rent can jump (especially in provinces without rent control)
Emotional comfortHome is where you raised your family — attachment matters
Estate valueHome passes to heirs, potentially with significant appreciation
Inflation hedgeReal estate generally keeps pace with or exceeds inflation
Reverse mortgage optionCan access equity later without selling (reverse mortgages are available from age 55)

Risk factors to consider

Risks of selling and renting

RiskWays to manage it
Rent increasesRent caps apply in some provinces (in Ontario, only to units first occupied on or before November 15, 2018)
Eviction (landlord’s own use, renoviction)Provincial tenant rights; a budget for a possible move
Investment underperformanceA lower withdrawal rate; a cash reserve
Outliving your moneyPlanning to a late age; annuities for guaranteed income
Loss of estate valueA trade-off between inheritance and spending in retirement
Rent-to-income ratio risingIf rent rises faster than investment income, the math deteriorates over time

Risks of staying

RiskWays to manage it
Large unexpected repairA home repair reserve
Accessibility needsModifications, or a later move
IsolationAging in a large house alone can be isolating
Cash-poor, house-richA HELOC or reverse mortgage can release equity
Property tax increasesSeveral provinces and municipalities offer seniors’ property tax deferral or relief

Decision framework

Sell-and-rent tends to fit when:

  • Your home equity is large relative to what a comparable rental costs.
  • You are house-rich but cash-poor — struggling with day-to-day retirement income.
  • Your home requires $20,000+ in deferred maintenance that you can’t afford.
  • You want to travel extensively or live in multiple locations.
  • You don’t have children who want to inherit the property.
  • You live in a market where home values are high relative to rents (such as Toronto or Vancouver).

Staying tends to fit when:

  • Local rent isn’t much cheaper than your ownership costs.
  • You have sufficient retirement income without needing to access home equity.
  • Your home is low-maintenance (condo, newer detached) with minimal upcoming capital costs.
  • You have strong community ties and moving would harm your well-being.
  • You want to leave the home to your heirs.
  • Your province has limited rent control, making long-term rent costs unpredictable.

Alternatives to selling outright

OptionHow it worksBest for
Reverse mortgageBorrow against equity; no payments until you sell, move out or pass awayCash-flow needs without leaving home
HELOCDraw equity as needed; interest-only payments allowedSpecific large expenses (renovations, medical)
Downsize to smaller owned homeSell, buy cheaper, invest the differenceWant ownership benefits + freed-up capital
Rent out part of your homeBasement suite or room rental incomeOffset costs while staying
Sale-leasebackSell your home to an investor, lease it backRare in Canada

Downsizing

Downsizing can free up a large part of a retiree’s home equity and lower ongoing housing costs. This page covers how much cash it releases, the tax rules, where to invest the proceeds, and the costs and steps involved. Broader retirement income planning is in the retirement planning guide, and this page is part of our guide to property types and owning a home in Canada.

The financial case for downsizing

How much equity can you unlock?

ScenarioHome soldNew homeCash releasedIncome at 4% a year
Detached → condo$900,000$500,000$355,000$14,200
Large detached → small detached$1,200,000$750,000$390,000$15,600
GTA detached → small-town detached$1,100,000$400,000$645,000$25,800
Detached → rental apartment$800,000$0 (renting)$760,000$30,400

Cash released is the sale price minus about 5% selling costs and the new home’s price, before land transfer tax and moving costs on the new home. The income column assumes the cash earns or is drawn at 4% a year.

Ongoing cost savings

Expense4-Bedroom Detached2-Bedroom CondoAnnual Savings
Property tax$5,500$3,000$2,500
Utilities$4,800$2,000$2,800
Home insurance$2,200$800$1,400
Maintenance / repairs$8,000 (1% of value)$1,000$7,000
Condo feesN/A$5,400−$5,400
Landscaping / snow removal$2,000$0$2,000
Total$22,500$12,200$10,300

In this example the smaller home costs about $10,300 a year less to run, after its condo fees. What condo fees cover, and how special assessments work, is explained in condo fees explained.

Tax implications

Principal residence exemption

A gain on selling a home that was your principal residence for every year you owned it is usually tax-free under the principal residence exemption, but the sale still has to be reported on Schedule 3 of the tax return (with Form T2091 if the home wasn’t your principal residence every year), and a late designation can bring a penalty even when no tax is owed. Years the home was rented out, and a second property such as a cottage, can leave part of a gain taxable; the rules, forms and examples are in our principal residence exemption guide, and gains on other property are covered under capital gains tax.

Investing the proceeds

AccountBenefitLimit
TFSATax-free growth and withdrawals$7,000 for 2026; up to $109,000 of total room for someone eligible since 2009 who has never contributed
Non-registered accountNo contribution limit; flexible accessInvestment income is taxable
RRSPTax-deductible contributionsUntil the end of the year you turn 71, with unused room
GICsSafe, predictable incomeReturns may not keep pace with inflation
AnnuityGuaranteed lifetime incomeIrreversible; less flexibility

Downsizing options

OptionProsCons
Smaller houseStill own property; no condo fees; yardStill have maintenance; less equity released
Condo / apartmentLow maintenance; amenities; lock-and-leaveCondo fees; less space; special levies possible
BungalowSingle-floor living for aging; accessibleMay be more expensive than expected in desirable areas
Retirement communitySocial; services on-site; designed for seniorsCosts can be high; less independence
RentMaximum equity released; no maintenanceNo equity building; rent increases; less stability
Move to smaller cityMuch lower cost; more equity freedDistance from family/friends; fewer services
Stay and renovateNo moving; familiar neighbourhoodCosts money; does not free up equity (see aging in place home modifications)

Buy or rent after downsizing

Buying a smaller home frees part of the equity and keeps the stability of ownership, the principal residence exemption on future gains and a property to leave to heirs. Renting frees all of the sale proceeds for investment and leaves no maintenance, in exchange for rent increases and less security of tenure; the full comparison is in selling your home and renting in retirement.

The downsizing process

StepDetailsTimeline
1. Financial assessmentCalculate equity, selling costs, LTT on new property, and net cash freed1–2 months before listing
2. Tax planningConfirm PR exemption eligibility; plan for investing proceedsConcurrent with step 1
3. Declutter and prepareSort belongings; donate/sell; stage the home1–3 months
4. List and sellWork with a realtor; price competitively1–3 months
5. Find a new homeBuy or rent; consider accessibility and future needs1–3 months
6. MoveHire movers; set up new home1–2 weeks
7. Invest proceedsDeploy cash into TFSA, non-reg, GICs, etc.Within 1 month of receiving funds
8. Update estate planRevise will, power of attorney, beneficiary designationsWithin 3 months

Selling costs to budget for

CostTypical Range
Real estate commissionNegotiable; Payotte’s industry survey puts the average at 4.09% of the sale price nationally (commission calculator)
Legal fees (sale)$800–$1,500
Staging$2,000–$5,000
Minor repairs / touch-ups$1,000–$5,000
Moving$1,500–$5,000
Land transfer tax (on new purchase)Varies by province (Ontario: $6,475 on $500,000)
Legal fees (purchase)$1,000–$2,000
Home inspection (new property)$400–$600
Total on a $900,000 sale and $500,000 purchaseAbout $40,175 to $70,575

Emotional considerations

ConcernWays people handle it
Attachment to the family homeTreating the move as the start of a new stage rather than a loss
Neighbourhood and communityStaying in the same neighbourhood in a smaller unit
Memories and possessionsPhotographing items with sentimental value; passing meaningful items to family
Loss of spaceThinking of it as right-sizing rather than downsizing
Family expectationsTalking openly about plans early
Fear of changeVisiting the new area or building several times before committing

Downsizing Checklist

6+ Months Before

TaskDone?
Run financial analysis (is it worth it?)☐
Consult financial advisor about tax/income impact☐
Research target areas and housing types☐
Get home appraised☐
Start decluttering☐
Tour potential new homes/condos☐

3-6 Months Before

TaskDone?
Interview real estate agents☐
Begin home repairs/improvements for sale☐
Sort belongings: keep, donate, sell, toss☐
Review condo fees and rules (if buying condo)☐
Consult accountant about capital gains implications☐
Update will and power of attorney☐

1-3 Months Before

TaskDone?
List home for sale☐
Arrange bridge financing if needed☐
Book moving company☐
Notify CRA, banks, pension providers of address change☐
Set up mail forwarding☐
Transfer or cancel utility accounts☐

When downsizing tends to make financial sense

SituationHow downsizing fits
Large home equity and a need for retirement incomeReleases equity that can be invested or drawn on
High yearly maintenance and property taxCan cut ongoing costs substantially
House too large: unused rooms, stairs are difficultPractical as well as financial benefits
Plans to move to a lower-cost regionFrees the most equity
Home paid off and ample retirement savingsLess financial need; the decision rests more on lifestyle
Weak local housing marketA lower sale price reduces the cash released
Still using the whole house (multigenerational living)Less to gain from a smaller home
Large mortgage balance remainingNet proceeds may be limited
🏠

Compare mortgage rates from 30+ lenders

Homewise searches options from over 30 banks and lenders and negotiates for you, free of charge. The online application takes about 5 minutes.

Get Started →

Disclosure: Homewise is a WealthNorth referral partner. WealthNorth may receive a referral fee if you use Homewise through this link. This does not affect your rate or cost.

Sources

The figures and rules on this page come from these sources, last checked against them between August 29, 2026 and October 1, 2026. How we check facts.