Skip to main content

TFSA Full? Where to Save Next and TFSA vs Non-Registered

Updated

Until new Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) room arrives, savings that don’t fit in your TFSA can go into other registered plans you qualify for, a spouse’s or common-law partner’s TFSA (as a gift to them), or a non-registered (taxable) account. They can also pay down debt. Below: who can use each option, how each is taxed, and how a non-registered account is taxed compared with a TFSA.

Is your TFSA really full, and when does new room arrive?

Your CRA account shows your TFSA contribution room under View TFSA details. Financial institutions send the CRA a year’s transactions at the end of February of the following year, so contributions made this year may not be in that figure yet. The room page covers this year’s TFSA limit and how to tell whether you are full or over. Contributing more than your room creates an excess amount that is subject to a monthly tax (TFSA penalty calculator). On January 1, the new year’s dollar limit is added to your room, together with the amount you withdrew the year before (TFSA withdrawal rules).

Where else can your savings go?

Listed by eligibility, not preference: the table starts with the options open to the fewest people. If your RRSP and FHSA room is used up too, what remains is a spouse’s or common-law partner’s TFSA, paying down debt, an RESP if you are saving for a child, and a non-registered account.

Who can use itOptionGoing inGrowth and coming out
First-time home buyersFHSAContributions generally deductibleSaving for a qualifying first home is tax-free, up to certain limits
Someone saving for a student’s post-secondary educationRESPContributions not deductibleGrants and earnings paid to the student as educational assistance payments are included in the student’s income
People with RRSP deduction roomRRSPDeductible up to your RRSP deduction limitPayments from the plan are generally taxed
People whose spouse or common-law partner has unused TFSA roomTheir TFSAA gift, within their own room; not deductibleThe gift and the income on it are not allocated back to you
Investors who have maxed out their registered room, or want no contribution or withdrawal rulesNon-registered accountNo contribution or withdrawal rulesInterest, dividends and capital gains are reported as income

An FHSA, if you are buying a first home

A first home savings account (FHSA) lets a first-time home buyer save to buy or build a qualifying first home tax-free, up to certain limits, and its contributions are generally deductible. Participation room is $8,000 in the first year you open one. If you don’t buy, the savings can go to your RRSP by direct transfer without immediate tax consequences, provided you have no excess FHSA amount (if you don’t buy).

The FHSA guide and FHSA vs TFSA vs RRSP have more.

An RESP, if you are saving for a child’s education

Registered education savings plan (RESP) contributions aren’t deductible, and the government provides grants where applicable. Grants and earnings are paid to the student as educational assistance payments for post-secondary education, and the student includes them in income. The RESP guide covers the grants.

An RRSP

A registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) is a retirement savings plan, and contributions up to your RRSP deduction limit can be deducted to reduce your tax. You generally pay tax when you receive payments from an RRSP. TFSA or RRSP first compares the two, and the RRSP guide covers the account.

A spouse’s or common-law partner’s TFSA

You may gift your spouse or common-law partner money so they can contribute to their own TFSA, within their own available room. The general attribution rule for a gift to a spouse or common-law partner: Income or loss from property you transfer or lend to your spouse or common-law partner (or someone who later becomes one) is taxed to you for the time you are resident in Canada and they are your spouse or partner. The Income Tax Act sets them aside for a gift for a spouse’s TFSA: The attribution rule is set aside for money you gift your spouse or common-law partner while it (or property that replaces it) is held in their TFSA, to the extent they have no excess TFSA amount. The gift and its income are therefore not allocated back to you. Funding a spouse’s TFSA has more.

Paying down debt

Money that pays down a loan saves the interest the loan would have charged on it, so its return is the loan’s interest rate. Paying off debt compares ways to do it.

TFSA vs a non-registered account: how is each taxed?

Interest, dividends and capital gains earned in a TFSA are generally tax-free, even when you withdraw them. In a non-registered account, interest, dividends and capital gains are reported as income. The Ontario Securities Commission’s investor site puts it plainly: such accounts are not tax-sheltered. Budget 2008, which proposed the TFSA, found the rate of return from saving in either a TFSA or an RRSP superior to unregistered saving.

IncomeIn a non-registered accountIn a TFSA
InterestIncluded in income, and on most investments made in 1990 or later reported each year as it is earnedGenerally tax-free
Canadian dividendsGrossed up and included in income; a dividend tax credit then reduces the taxGenerally tax-free
Foreign dividendsReported in Canadian dollars, with no dividend tax credit; a foreign tax credit may be claimed for foreign tax paidGenerally tax-free
Capital gainsReported when you sell or transfer the property; 50% of the gain (the inclusion rate) is taxableGenerally tax-free

The dividends come from taxable Canadian corporations; foreign dividends don't qualify for the credit. The dividend tax credit guide explains the gross-up and the credit, and how a non-registered account compares with an RRSP is on the RRSP side.

The Ontario Securities Commission’s investor site notes that some investment income attracts less tax than others, which creates opportunities to lower overall taxes by choosing which accounts hold which kinds of assets. In a taxable account, interest is included in income, Canadian dividends get the dividend tax credit, and a capital gain is taxable at the inclusion rate. In a TFSA, the three are generally tax-free. Under Article XXI of the Canada-US tax treaty, US dividends paid to an RRSP or RRIF are exempt from US withholding; in a TFSA, FHSA, RESP or taxable account the standard 15% treaty rate applies, and only in a taxable account can it be recovered as a foreign tax credit. The asset location guide and US dividend withholding in a TFSA go further.

What does a non-registered account offer that a TFSA doesn’t?

The Ontario Securities Commission’s investor site says a non-registered account can suit investors who have maxed out their registered room, or who want an account without registered plans’ contribution and withdrawal rules. Capital losses on investments held there are generally applied against capital gains of the same year: What is left (a net capital loss) can reduce taxable capital gains in any of the three years before, or in any future year. In a TFSA, income, losses and gains are not included in computing income, and a loss there doesn’t count as a withdrawal and never becomes new contribution room.

Moving investments into your TFSA when new room arrives

Once new room arrives, you may contribute qualified investments from a non-registered account to your TFSA in kind, without selling them first. A contribution in kind is a disposition of the property at its fair market value at the time of the contribution. If the fair market value is more than the property's cost, you report the capital gain. A loss on a disposition of property to a trust governed by your TFSA, FHSA, RRIF, RDSP, deferred profit sharing plan or employees profit sharing plan is nil, so it can't be claimed. Moving investments in kind and the superficial loss rules have the details.

Sources

The figures and rules on this page come from these sources, last checked against them between August 29, 2026 and October 1, 2026. How we check facts.