Testamentary vs Inter Vivos Trust: Key Differences in Canada
Updated
An inter vivos trust is set up during the settlor’s lifetime; a testamentary trust is created by a will when the person dies. This page compares how each is taxed, the graduated rate estate and qualified disability trust exceptions, and the situations each tends to suit. It is part of the corporate, trust and estate tax guides; the most common inter vivos trust for tax planning is covered in the family trust guide.
A parent’s will creates a testamentary trust for their 10-year-old child:
Trustee manages assets until child is 25
Funds available for education, health, maintenance
Capital distributed in stages (e.g., 1/3 at 25, 30, 35)
Protects inheritance from poor decisions
Spousal Trust Comparison
Inter Vivos Spousal Trust (Alter Ego/Joint Partner)
Feature
Details
Creator age
65+
Beneficiaries
Settlor and/or spouse only
Rollover
Assets transfer at cost
21-year rule
Applies
Probate
Avoided
Testamentary Spousal Trust
Feature
Details
Created
At death via will
Income beneficiary
Surviving spouse
Capital beneficiary
Children or others
Rollover
Assets transfer at cost
21-year rule
Starts at death
Probate
Estate goes through probate
Tax Planning Considerations
Attribution, TOSI and the 21-Year Rule
Three rules apply to both kinds of trust, with differences in timing or reach:
Attribution: income on property a living settlor transfers to an inter vivos trust for a spouse or minor can be taxed back to the settlor; a testamentary trust generally has no attribution because the settlor has died. The rules are explained in attribution rules in Canada.
Tax on split income: income from a family business that either kind of trust passes to related minors, and to adults who don’t meet an exclusion, can be taxed at the top rate under TOSI.
21-year rule: an inter vivos trust is deemed to dispose of its capital property 21 years after it was created, a testamentary trust 21 years after the death; how that works and the usual planning are in the family trust guide’s 21-year rule section. Both require planning to avoid forced capital gains recognition.