Growth pick — lowest yield but highest capital appreciation potential
10-Year Total Return (Approximate)
Bank
$10K Invested 10 Years Ago
Avg Annual Return
NA
~$32,000
~12.5%
RY
~$28,000
~10.8%
BMO
~$24,000
~9.2%
TD
~$20,000
~7.2%
CM
~$22,000
~8.2%
BNS
~$16,000
~4.8%
Includes dividends reinvested. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
How to Pick
By Goal
Goal
Best Bank
Why
Quality and safety
RY
Strongest balance sheet, best ROE
Highest income
BNS
6% yield
Growth + income
NA
Fastest growing, lowest payout ratio
Value play
TD, CM
Trading below historical averages
US exposure
BMO, TD
Significant US operations
Dividend Income on $50,000
Bank
Yield
Annual Dividends
Quarterly Payment
BNS
6.0%
$3,000
$750
TD
4.8%
$2,400
$600
CM
4.8%
$2,400
$600
BMO
4.5%
$2,250
$563
RY
3.8%
$1,900
$475
NA
3.5%
$1,750
$438
Canadian Bank Stocks vs Bank ETFs
Feature
Individual Stocks
ZEB (Big 6 ETF)
VDY (Dividend ETF)
Diversification
1 stock
6 banks equally
50+ stocks
MER
$0
0.28%
0.22%
Rebalancing
Manual
Automatic (equal-weight)
Automatic
Concentration
100% 1 company
100% banks
~55% banks
Customization
Full control
None
None
Best for
Conviction picks
Pure bank exposure
Broad dividend
Which Account to Hold Bank Stocks
Account
Tax Treatment
Notes
TFSA
Dividends tax-free
✅ Best for Canadian bank stocks
RRSP
Tax-deferred
✅ Good, especially if near retirement
Non-registered
Eligible dividend tax credit
✅ Dividends taxed favourably
Canadian bank dividends receive the eligible dividend tax credit in non-registered accounts, making them one of the most tax-efficient equity investments.