Investing in US markets from Canada is straightforward with the right setup. The three decisions that matter most: which broker you use, how you convert currency, and which account type holds each investment.
Norbert’s Gambit: step-by-step walkthrough
Norbert’s Gambit is the method most Canadian investors use to convert CAD to USD at near-interbank rates.
Step 1: Buy DLR.TO in your Canadian account
DLR is an ETF (Horizons US Dollar Currency ETF) that holds US dollars. Each share is worth approximately $10 USD.
- Log into your broker
- Buy DLR.TO in the CAD side of your account (RRSP CAD, TFSA CAD, or non-reg CAD)
- DLR.TO is priced in CAD; each share ≈ $10 USD × exchange rate (e.g., at 1.38, each share ≈ $13.80 CAD)
- Buy as many shares as you need to cover your USD amount
Step 2: Wait for settlement
DLR.TO settles T+1 (next business day). Wait until fully settled before proceeding.
Step 3: Journal shares from CAD to USD
This is the key step that most brokers require a phone call to complete.
- Call your broker’s trade desk
- Say: “I would like to journal my DLR.TO shares from the CAD side [account number] to DLR.U.TO on the USD side [same or linked account number]”
- The rep converts your DLR.TO shares to DLR.U.TO in the USD sub-account
- DLR.U.TO is the same ETF but priced in USD (~$10 USD/share)
TD Direct Investing: can do this online via “Move Securities” without a phone call. Questrade: phone call required. IBKR: use the online FX converter instead (cheaper, no journaling needed).
Step 4: Sell DLR.U.TO
Once the journal is complete, sell DLR.U.TO. You receive approximately $10 USD per share minus a small bid-ask spread (~0.01–0.02 USD per share).
Step 5: Buy your US ETF
Use the USD proceeds to buy VTI, VOO, or your chosen US security.
Broker comparison for US equity investing
| Broker | US trade commissions | FX spread | USD in RRSP/TFSA | Norbert’s Gambit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Questrade | $0 buy / ECN on sell | 1.5–2% | Yes | Yes (phone) |
| Wealthsimple Trade (Premium) | $0 | ~0.5% Premium / 1.5% free | Yes (2025) | No |
| TD Direct Investing | $9.99/trade | 1.5% | Yes | Online (Move Securities) |
| RBC Direct Investing | $9.95/trade | 1.5% | Yes | Phone |
| NBDB (National Bank) | $0 | 1.5% | Yes | Yes (phone) |
| Interactive Brokers (IBKR) | $0.005/share (min $1) | ~0.1–0.2 bps | Yes | Direct FX convert |
| BMO InvestorLine | $9.95/trade | 1.5% | Yes | Phone |
Withholding tax by account: quick reference
| Account type | US-listed ETF withholding | Recovery? |
|---|---|---|
| RRSP, RRIF, LIRA, LIF, PRPP | 0% (treaty Article XXI) | N/A — nothing withheld |
| TFSA, FHSA | 15% | None — permanently lost |
| Non-registered | 15% | Yes — Form T2209, Line 40500 |
T1 reporting checklist for US investment income
| Income type | Account | T1 line | Form needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| US dividends received | Non-registered | Line 12100 | T5 slip from broker |
| Foreign tax withheld | Non-registered | Line 40500 | Form T2209 |
| Capital gain on US stocks | Non-registered | Schedule 3 → Line 12700 | No form — calculate manually |
| All US income in RRSP | RRSP | Not reported | Nothing until withdrawal |
| All US income in TFSA | TFSA | Not reported | Nothing ever |
| T1135 — foreign property over $100K | Non-registered | Filed separately | Form T1135 |