Skip to main content

Mortgage Default Insurance in Canada: CMHC, Sagen & Canada Guaranty Compared (2026)

Updated

If your down payment is less than 20%, mortgage default insurance is mandatory in Canada. It adds thousands to your mortgage — but it also makes homeownership possible with as little as 5% down. Here is exactly how it works, what it costs, and how the three insurers compare.

How mortgage default insurance works

Component Details
Purpose Protects the lender (not you) if you default
When required Down payment less than 20%
Premium range 2.80%–4.00% of mortgage amount
How it’s paid Added to your mortgage balance (increases your mortgage amount)
PST applicable Yes — in Ontario (8%), Quebec (9%), Manitoba (7%), Saskatchewan (6%) — paid upfront at closing
Who chooses the insurer Your lender — you do not select
Maximum purchase price $1,000,000 (insured mortgages cannot exceed this)
Maximum amortization 25 years (insured mortgages; 30-year amortization allowed for first-time buyers on new builds as of 2024 changes)

Premium rates (all three insurers)

Down Payment Loan-to-Value (LTV) Insurance Premium (% of mortgage)
5% (minimum on first $500K) 95.01%–95% 4.00%
10% 90.01%–95% 3.10%
15% 85.01%–90% 2.80%
20%+ 80% or less Not required

Premium calculation examples

Home Price Down Payment Down % Mortgage Premium Rate Insurance Premium Total Mortgage
$400,000 $20,000 5% $380,000 4.00% $15,200 $395,200
$500,000 $25,000 5% $475,000 4.00% $19,000 $494,000
$500,000 $50,000 10% $450,000 3.10% $13,950 $463,950
$500,000 $75,000 15% $425,000 2.80% $11,900 $436,900
$700,000 $45,000 ~6.4% $655,000 4.00% $26,200 $681,200
$1,000,000 $75,000 7.5% $925,000 4.00% $37,000 $962,000

Note on purchases above $500,000: The minimum down payment is 5% on the first $500,000 and 10% on the portion above $500,000.

Down payment calculation for homes above $500,000

Home Price Minimum Down Payment Calculation
$500,000 $25,000 5% × $500,000
$600,000 $35,000 (5% × $500,000) + (10% × $100,000)
$700,000 $45,000 (5% × $500,000) + (10% × $200,000)
$800,000 $55,000 (5% × $500,000) + (10% × $300,000)
$999,999 $74,999 (5% × $500,000) + (10% × $499,999)
$1,000,000 $200,000 20% required — cannot be insured

PST on mortgage default insurance

In some provinces, you must pay PST on the insurance premium at closing — in cash, not added to the mortgage.

Province PST Rate PST on $19,000 Premium (5% down, $500K home)
Ontario 8% $1,520
Quebec 9% $1,710
Manitoba 7% $1,330
Saskatchewan 6% $1,140
BC Exempt $0
Alberta No PST $0
Atlantic provinces Exempt $0

This is an additional closing cost many buyers forget. In Ontario, buying a $500,000 home with 5% down means you owe $1,520 in PST at closing on top of your other costs.

CMHC vs Sagen vs Canada Guaranty

Feature CMHC Sagen Canada Guaranty
Government entity Crown corporation Private (publicly traded) Private
Market share ~50% ~30% ~20%
Premium rates Standard schedule Same schedule Same schedule
Max purchase price $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000
Max amortization (standard) 25 years 25 years 25 years
Self-employed borrowers Available (may require more documentation) Available Available
New-to-Canada program Yes Yes Yes
Non-traditional credit Limited Some flexibility Some flexibility
Rental properties Available (different premiums) Available Available
Extended amortization (30-year, first-time + new build) Available (2024 change) Available Available

Why lenders choose one insurer over another

You do not pick the insurer — your lender does. Lenders consider:

Factor Details
Risk appetite CMHC is more conservative; Sagen and Canada Guaranty may approve files CMHC declines
Relationship Lenders have bulk insurance agreements with specific insurers
Property type Some insurers are more flexible with certain property types
Borrower profile Self-employed, new-to-Canada, or non-traditional borrowers may be steered to a specific insurer

Practical impact: If your mortgage application is declined by one insurer, your broker can submit to another. This is one advantage of using a mortgage broker — they have access to all three.

Insured vs insurable vs uninsurable mortgages

Category Insurance Status Down Payment Max Amortization Rate Impact
Insured Default insurance required and premium paid by borrower Less than 20% 25 years (30 for qualifying FTBs) Lowest rates
Insurable Lender obtains portfolio insurance (you don’t pay premium) 20%+ 25 years Middle rates
Uninsurable Cannot be insured by any insurer 20%+ Up to 30 years Highest rates

Why insured mortgages get lower rates

Reason Details
Zero risk for lender If you default, the insurer pays the lender in full
Lower capital requirements Banks need less reserve capital against insured mortgages
Securitization Insured mortgages can be bundled and sold as Canada Mortgage Bonds
Rate benefit Insured borrowers often get 0.10–0.20% lower rates than uninsured

The 20% paradox

Putting exactly 20% down sometimes results in a higher interest rate than putting 19.99% down and paying insurance. The insurance gives you access to insured rates that can offset the premium cost.

Scenario Down Payment Insurance Premium Rate Monthly Payment 5-Year Cost
20% down (uninsured) $100,000 on $500K $0 4.50% $2,220 $133,200
19.99% down (insured) $99,950 on $500K ~$11,200 4.30% $2,216 $132,960 + insurance

The math is close — in some rate environments, paying insurance to get a lower rate actually saves money over 5 years. Ask your broker to run both scenarios.

Common situations and rules

Porting insurance when you move

Detail Rule
Moving to a new home Insurance can be ported — transferred to the new mortgage
Increasing mortgage amount Top-up insurance may be required on the additional amount
Switching lenders Insurance transfers with the mortgage when you switch at renewal

Refinancing

Detail Rule
Refinancing an insured mortgage You lose the insurance — refinanced mortgages are uninsurable
Getting insurance back Not possible — once you break the insured mortgage, it’s gone
Rate impact You move to uninsurable rates (typically higher)

Self-employed borrowers

Insurer Self-Employed Treatment
CMHC Accepts traditional income verification; may accept stated income with 2 years’ business history
Sagen Business-for-self program — may accept 1–2 years’ income documents
Canada Guaranty Stated income program available in some cases

How to minimize insurance costs

Strategy Details Savings
Increase down payment to 10% Premium drops from 4.0% to 3.10% 0.90% of mortgage (~$4,050 on $450K)
Increase down payment to 15% Premium drops to 2.80% 1.20% of mortgage (~$5,100 on $425K)
Increase down payment to 20% No insurance required Full premium savings (~$15,000–$20,000)
Gifted down payment Family gift to reach higher down payment tier Varies
FHSA + RRSP HBP Maximize tax-advantaged savings for larger down payment Up to $75,000

Insurance premium impact on monthly payment

On a $500,000 home at 4.5% over 25 years:

Down Payment Mortgage + Insurance Monthly Payment Premium Cost Over 25 Years
5% ($25,000) $494,000 $2,742 $19,000 (+ ~$11,600 interest on it)
10% ($50,000) $463,950 $2,575 $13,950 (+ ~$8,500 interest)
15% ($75,000) $436,900 $2,425 $11,900 (+ ~$7,300 interest)
20% ($100,000) $400,000 $2,220 $0

The true cost of insurance includes the interest you pay on the premium over the life of the mortgage. $19,000 in insurance premiums costs you ~$30,600 total over 25 years including interest.


🏠

Get the best mortgage rate in Canada — in minutes

Homewise negotiates with 30+ banks and lenders for you. Free, 5 minutes, no credit check.

Get Started →

Affiliate disclosure: WealthNorth may earn a commission if you apply through this link. This does not affect your rate or cost.