Is it cheaper to buy or lease a car in Canada?

Buying is cheaper long-term if you keep the car 7-10+ years. Leasing has lower monthly payments but you never build equity. Over 10 years, buying and keeping a car can save $15,000-$40,000+ compared to continuous leasing.

What are the advantages of leasing in Canada?

Lower monthly payments, driving a new car every 3-4 years, warranty coverage for the entire lease, and no trade-in hassle. For self-employed Canadians, lease payments and HST can be partially deducted as a business expense.

Can I write off a car lease on my taxes in Canada?

Self-employed individuals and business owners can deduct a portion of lease payments (up to $950/month + HST for 2025). The business-use percentage of lease payments, gas, insurance, and maintenance are all deductible. Employees may deduct if they have a T2200 form.

Is it better to buy used or lease new?

Buying a 2-3 year old used car is almost always the cheapest option. You avoid the steepest depreciation (20-30% in the first 2 years) and have lower insurance costs. Leasing a new car costs significantly more than buying used over time.

Should I Buy or Lease a Car in Canada 2026?

Quick Comparison

Factor	Buy (Finance)	Buy (Cash)	Lease
Monthly payment	Higher	$0	Lower
Ownership	Yes (after payoff)	Yes	No
Total cost (7-10 years)	Lower	Lowest	Highest
Down payment	10-20% typical	100%	$0-$2,000
Mileage limits	None	None	16,000-24,000 km/year
Maintenance after warranty	Your responsibility	Your responsibility	Covered (during lease)
Modification/customization	Yes	Yes	No
End of term	Own the car	Own the car	Return or buy out
Trade-in value	Yes	Yes	No (unless positive equity)
Best for	Long-term owners	Cash-rich, long-term	Business use, new car every 3-4yrs

Total Cost Comparison: $40,000 Vehicle Over 10 Years

Option 1: Buy New (Finance, 5-Year Loan, 7% Rate)

Year	Payment	Cumulative Paid	Car Value
1	$9,504 ($792/mo)	$9,504	$32,000
3	$9,504	$28,512	$24,000
5 (loan paid off)	$9,504	$47,520	$18,000
7	$0	$47,520	$13,000
10	$0	$47,520	$8,000
Total ownership cost		$47,520 - $8,000 trade-in = $39,520

Option 2: Lease New (Repeated 4-Year Leases)

Lease Term	Monthly Payment	Total Lease Cost	End of Lease
Lease 1 (Years 1-4)	$500/mo	$24,000	Return car
Lease 2 (Years 5-8)	$525/mo (new car, inflation)	$25,200	Return car
Lease 3 (Years 9-10, 2 of 4 years)	$550/mo	$13,200	Still leasing
Total lease cost (10 years)		$62,400	Own nothing

Option 3: Buy Used (3 Years Old, $28,000, Finance 5 Years)

Item	Amount
Purchase price (3-year old)	$28,000
Total financed (5 years, 7%)	$33,264
Drive for 10 years (car now 13 years old)	No payments for years 6-10
Trade-in value at year 10	$3,000-$5,000
Total cost	$28,264-$30,264

Summary

Option	10-Year Total Cost	Own Car at End?
Buy new (finance)	~$39,500	Yes ($8K value)
Lease repeatedly	~$62,400	No
Buy used (3yr old, finance)	~$28,000-$30,000	Yes ($3-5K value)
Savings: Used vs Lease		~$32,000-$34,000

Monthly Payment Comparison ($40,000 Vehicle)

Method	Monthly Payment	Duration	Total Payments
Cash purchase	$0	—	$40,000 (one-time)
Finance (5yr, 7%)	$792	60 months	$47,520
Finance (7yr, 7%)	$604	84 months	$50,736
Lease (4yr)	$480-$550	48 months	$23,040-$26,400

Depreciation: The Hidden Cost

Vehicle Age	Value Remaining	Annual Depreciation
New (day 1)	$40,000	—
Year 1	$32,000-$34,000	15-20%
Year 2	$28,000-$30,000	10-12%
Year 3	$24,000-$26,000	8-10%
Year 5	$18,000-$20,000	5-8%
Year 7	$12,000-$15,000	3-5%
Year 10	$7,000-$10,000	2-3%

By buying a 3-year-old car, you avoid the steepest depreciation (35-40% in 3 years) and save $12,000-$16,000 on a $40,000 vehicle.

Lease Costs to Watch For

Cost	Typical Amount
Excess mileage (over limit)	$0.10-$0.25/km
Disposition fee (at return)	$300-$500
Excess wear and tear	$500-$2,000
Early termination penalty	$2,000-$10,000+
Gap insurance	Included or $300-$500
License/registration	Same as buying

Mileage Penalty Example

Annual Limit	Your Driving	Excess/Year	4-Year Penalty (at $0.15/km)
20,000 km	25,000 km	5,000 km	$3,000
20,000 km	30,000 km	10,000 km	$6,000

Tax Benefits (Self-Employed/Business Use)

Deduction	Lease	Buy (Finance)	Buy (Cash)
Monthly deduction cap	$950/mo + HST (2025)	CCA (capital cost allowance)	CCA
HST on payments	Deductible (business %)	Input tax credit (business %)	Input tax credit
Interest deduction	Included in lease payment	Up to $300/month (2025)	N/A
Business-use % deductible	Yes (gas, insurance, maintenance too)	Yes	Yes
Simplicity	Very simple (monthly expense)	More complex (CCA calculations)	CCA calculations

Example: 50% Business Use, $600/Month Lease

Item	Annual Cost	Business Deduction (50%)
Lease payments ($600/mo)	$7,200	$3,600
Gas	$3,000	$1,500
Insurance	$2,000	$1,000
Maintenance	$500	$250
Total deductions		$6,350
Tax savings (at 30% rate)		~$1,905

Decision Framework

Your Situation	Best Choice	Why
Keep cars 7+ years	Buy (new or used)	Lowest total cost
Want newest car always	Lease	New car every 3-4 years
Drive 25,000+ km/year	Buy	Avoid mileage penalties
Self-employed (business use)	Lease	Simpler tax deduction
Cash-rich, want lowest cost	Buy used with cash	Absolute cheapest option
Limited budget (need lower payments)	Lease (short term) or buy used	Lease has lower monthly, but buy used is better long-term
Want to modify/customize	Buy	Lease restricts modifications
Credit score building	Finance (buy)	Loan builds credit; lease may not
Uncertain future (may move, job change)	Lease	Easier to walk away at term end

Best Strategy: Buy Used, Invest the Savings

Step	Details
1	Buy a reliable 3-year-old car ($25,000-$30,000 vs $40,000 new)
2	Finance if needed, or use savings
3	Keep for 7-10 years
4	Invest monthly savings ($200-$400/mo) in TFSA
Savings over 10 years	$24,000-$48,000 invested → grows to $35,000-$75,000

→ Back to: Personal Finance Guide